Difference between revisions of "Confluence and (BlueSpice) MediaWiki"

From mwstake
Jump to: navigation, search
(links links links)
Line 11: Line 11:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Unlimited Spaces
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Unlimited Spaces
Line 60: Line 60:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Backup and Restore
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Backup and Restore
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
 
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|WikiCopy (2016)
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|WikiCopy (2016)
 +
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|  
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|  
 
|-
 
|-
Line 75: Line 75:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Create Rich Content (=Description of some wiki use cases)
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Create Rich Content (=Description of some wiki use cases)
Line 193: Line 193:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Rich Text Editor
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Rich Text Editor
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="313"|VisualEditor
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="313"|VisualEditor
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="247"|  
+
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="247"|VisualEditor
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="182"|VisualEditor
+
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="182"|
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Drag& Drop Editing
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Drag& Drop Editing
Line 283: Line 283:
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Embed Web Widgets
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Embed Web Widgets
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
| style="font-weight: 400;"|  
+
| style="font-weight: 400;"|[http://www.mediawikiwidgets.org/ MediaWiki Widgets]
| style="font-weight: 400;"|MediaWiki Widgets
+
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|InsertImages
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|InsertImages
Line 328: Line 328:
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Find&Replace
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Find&Replace
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|VisualEditor
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|VisualEditor
| style="font-weight: 400;"|  
+
| style="font-weight: 400;"|[https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension:Replace_Text Replace Text]
| style="font-weight: 400;"|ReplaceText
+
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|ConcurrentEditing
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|ConcurrentEditing
Line 363: Line 363:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Task List Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Task List Macro
Line 378: Line 378:
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Expand Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Expand Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
| style="font-weight: 400;"|  
+
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Tempate
+
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Add more macros
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Add more macros
Line 423: Line 423:
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|User Profile Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|User Profile Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 +
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Gallery Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Gallery Macro
Line 438: Line 438:
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Note Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Note Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 +
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|ProfilePictureMacro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|ProfilePictureMacro
Line 458: Line 458:
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Tip Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Tip Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 +
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Page Index Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Page Index Macro
Line 473: Line 473:
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Office Excel Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Office Excel Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 +
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Page Tree Macros
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Page Tree Macros
Line 553: Line 553:
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|View PDF Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|View PDF Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
| style="font-weight: 400;"|  
+
| style="font-weight: 400;"|[https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension:PdfHandler PDF Handler]
| style="font-weight: 400;"|PDF Viewer
+
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Navigation Map Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Navigation Map Macro
Line 588: Line 588:
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Column Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Column Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 +
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|HTML Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|HTML Macro
Line 603: Line 603:
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Section Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Section Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|-
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Template
 +
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Space Details Macro
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Space Details Macro
Line 701: Line 701:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" |Create Task List
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" |Create Task List
Line 745: Line 745:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Attach your Files
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Attach your Files
Line 824: Line 824:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|  
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|  
| style="font-weight: 400;"|  
+
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Multiupload (Plugin)
| style="font-weight: 400;"|Multiupload
+
| style="font-weight: 400;"|
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|  
 
| style="font-weight: 400;"|  
 
|}
 
|}
Line 834: Line 834:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" |Stay up to Date
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" |Stay up to Date
Line 921: Line 921:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Search anything
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Search anything
Line 989: Line 989:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
  
 
|-
 
|-
Line 1,029: Line 1,029:
 
|}
 
|}
 
==<br />"Jira Integration"==
 
==<br />"Jira Integration"==
-
+
Confluence offers a bundle of extensions for their software Jira
  
 
=="Installation"==
 
=="Installation"==
Line 1,036: Line 1,036:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Guided Upgrades
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Guided Upgrades
Line 1,105: Line 1,105:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Customize
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Customize
Line 1,178: Line 1,178:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|[https://help.bluespice.com/index.php/DashBoards Dashboards]
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|[https://help.bluespice.com/index.php/DashBoards Dashboards]
Line 1,257: Line 1,257:
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="187"|Confluence
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Confluence Groups
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="187"|Confluence Groups
Line 1,336: Line 1,336:
 
! width="187"|Topic
 
! width="187"|Topic
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
 
! width="313"|BlueSpice pro
! width="247"|BlueSpice Packages
+
! width="247"|MediaWiki
! width="182"|MediaWiki / SMW
+
! width="182"|SMW
 
|-
 
|-
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="270"|[https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Help:Templates Templating] and [https://www.semantic-mediawiki.org/wiki/Semantic_MediaWiki Semantic]
 
| style="font-weight: 400;" width="270"|[https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Help:Templates Templating] and [https://www.semantic-mediawiki.org/wiki/Semantic_MediaWiki Semantic]

Revision as of 08:10, 8 March 2016

Comparison of features along the official Confluence Full Features List to share ideas about further developments for MediaWiki third party user.

Notifications:

  • This is a draft
  • The feature list of BlueSpice here is not complete. This overview is meant as a "response" to the Confluence list to identify strengths and weak points in both systems. It would be helpfull to have an another listing of BlueSpice / MediaWiki extensions and a response by Confluence.

"Spaces"[edit]

Confluence "Spaces" is an equivalent to the MediaWiki "Namespaces"

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Unlimited Spaces Unlimited Namespaces
Space Directory UserSidebar
Categorize Spaces -
Space Permissions PermissionManager
Browse by Label CategoryPage
Archive Spaces NamespaceManager(?)
Export Content UniversalExport (PDF, DOCX, HTML)
Publish Blogs Blog
Default Permissions -
Backup and Restore WikiCopy (2016)
Space Sidebar UserSidebar

"Pages"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Create Rich Content (=Description of some wiki use cases) Create Rich Content (=Description of some wiki use cases)
Blueprints - Diverse Semantic Templates
Page Templates PageTemplates
Like Pages RatedComments / Rating
Share Pages -
Import Word Documents VisualEditor (BlueSpice)
Change Comments Summary (=MediaWiki Standard)
Restrict Pages PageAccess
Rename Pages Move (=MedaWiki Standard)
Export Pages UniversalExport (PDF e.a.)
Export Tables
Start Discussions Discussion (=MediaWiki Standard) LiquidThreads
Trackback Links -
Page Hierarchy Subpages (=MediaWiki Standard)
Page Versioning History (=MediaWiki Standard)
Recover Deleted Pages Deletion Log (=MediaWiki Standard)
Move & Copy Pages Move (=MedaWiki Standard)
Rendered Page Diffs Visual Diff
Add Labels Category (=MediaWiki Standard)
- Interwikilinks
- Cite
- Countthings

"Editor"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Rich Text Editor VisualEditor VisualEditor
Drag& Drop Editing PasteImage
Page Layouts -
Autocomplete for Links InsertLink (with autocomplete)
Embed Office Documents -
Keyboard Shortcuts -
Autoconvert for Links -
Advanced Table Editing InsertTables
Autoconvert for Attachements -
Autocomplete for Attachements InsertFile (with autocomplete)
Autocomplete for Macros InsertMagic (with autocomplete)
Add Multimedia Content -
Page Drafts SaferEdit (will be replaced)
Copy&Paste Images PasteImage
@mention others -
Autoformatting -
Property Panels -
Embed Web Widgets - MediaWiki Widgets
InsertImages InsertFile
Resize&Link Images InsertFile
Link to Antything InsertLink
EasyFormatting VisualEditor
MacroBrowser InsertMagic
Drag&Drop -
ApplyImageEffects -
PageTemplates PageTemplates
Find&Replace VisualEditor Replace Text
ConcurrentEditing EditConflict
ResponsiveEditor VisualEditor (FullScreen)
Assign Tasks -
- Signature
??Category-System?

"Macros"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Task List Macro Checklist (German description)
Status Macro Checklist (German description)
Expand Macro - Template
Add more macros -
Contributors Macro Editors
Change History Macro SmartList
Content by user Macro UserContribution
Chart Macro Semantic Result Formats
Recently Updated Macro Smartlist
Network Macro Userlist
Info Macro -
User Profile Macro - Template
Gallery Macro Gallery Tag
Favorite Pages Macro PagesVisited
Note Macro - Template
ProfilePictureMacro -
Panel Macro Poem
RSS Feed Macro RSS Feed
Tip Macro - Template
Page Index Macro AllPages, WikiExplorer
Content by Label Macro CategoryPages / DPL
Office Excel Macro - Template
Page Tree Macros CategoryTree, Bookmaker, Breadcrumbs
Page Tree Search Macro -
Popular Labels Macro TagCloud
Labels List Macro -
Recently Used Labels Macro -
Jira Issues Macro -
Children Macro -
Office PowerPoint Macro -
Popular Labels Macro WikiCategroyTagCloud
Related Labels Macro SimilarPages
LiveSearch Macro Search Tag
Office Word Macro -
Live Search Macro Inputbox
Search Results Macro -
Recently Used Labels MAcro -
View PDF Macro - PDF Handler
Navigation Map Macro -
Table of Content Macro Article Navigation (TOC)
Include Page Macro Templates
Anchor Macro Anchor
Excerpt Macro -
Excerpt Include Macro -
Column Macro - Template
HTML Macro HTML input possible (MediaWiki Standard)
Widget Connector MediaWiki Widgets
Section Macro - Template
Space Details Macro -
Code Block Macro SyntaxHighlight
Attachements Macro -
Blog Posts Macro BlogTag
Spaces List Macro -
Page Properties Report Macro StateBar
Page Properties Macro Semantic MediaWiki
Multimedia Macro EmbedVideo
Checklist
ImageMap
Inputbox
Math
ParserFunctions
Poem
Quiz
Whosonline
HideTitle
div Tags, Switches and Variables

"Tasks"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Create Task List -
Assign Tasks -
Tasks From Notification -
Personal Task List -
Task Notifications -
Mobile Ready MobileFrontend
Personal Task List -

"Attachement"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Attach your Files Files
Drag&Drop - / WebDAV
Label Attachements File Categories
Search Attachments Search Files
Embed Office Files -
Attachement Versioning File Versioning
Bulk Download -
Link Attachements InsertLink
Control Attachement Size Upload Maximum
Display Attachement Lists -
WebDAV WebDAV
Preview Attached Office Files -
Edit Attached Office Files WebDAV
Attachements Macro -
NSFileRepo
Multiupload (Plugin)

"Notifications"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Stay up to Date Notifications / Echo
Popular Content Summary -
Mobile Ready -
Autowatch Watchlist
Daily Email Reports Daily / Weekly Reports
Share Pages and Blogs -
Manage Watcher ResponsibleEditors
Watch Spaces Notifications (German description)
Watch Pages Watchlist
Watch all Blogs -
Network Notifications -
Jira Notifications -
Minor Edits Minor Edits
Follow Notifications -
RSS Subscriptions RSSFeeder / RSSStandards
Watch Blog Posts in a Space BlogTag

"Search"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Search anything Search anything (ExtendedSearch)
Search Filter Facetted Search
Browse Recently Viewed PagesVisited
Borwse Related Labels Similar Pages
Advaced Search Advanced Search
Search your Email -
Livesearch Macro TagSearch
Search inside Attachement File Search
Quick Navigation Search as you type
Preview Attachement -
Browser Search Browser Search
Did you mean Fuzzy Search

"Mobile"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Browse Activity MobileFrontend
View Pages&Blogs MobileFrontend
Quick Search MobileFrontend
Make Contributions MobileFrontend
Track Notifications MobileFrontend
View User Profiles -
Manage Tasks -


"Jira Integration"
[edit]

Confluence offers a bundle of extensions for their software Jira

"Installation"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Guided Upgrades -
Connect to Jira -
Buildt-in Database - ExternalData?
Guided Installer Installer
Administration WikiAdmin
Bundled Database Drivers -
Unlimited Developer Licenses Testsystem
Import other Wikis -
Troubleshoot Issues -
Site Backup - WikiCopy (2016)
Internationalisation Internationalisation
Server / Cloud Server / Cloud

"Customize"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Customize Flexiskin
Universal Plugin Manager Marketplace / Extension Store (2016 / 2017)
Massive Plugin Ecosystem Extensions on Mediwiki.org and elsewhere
Content Templates (ongoing)
Custom Layouts / Color Schemes NamespaceCSS / Sidebars
Welcome Message -
Remote Interfaces API
Themes Skins
Bundled Themes Content Templates (ongoing)
Logo Logo
Full Source Code Access GPL
Custom Stylesheets Custom CSS
TopMenubar Customizer

"Personal"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Dashboards Dashboards (User / Admin)
Status Updates Notifications
Hover Profile -
People Directory Userlist
Custom Starting Page Dashboards (User / Admin)
Networks Watchlist
Personal Spaces UserPage
User Profiles UsePreferences / UserPreferences
Recently Viewed Content PagesVisited
Favorites UserSidebar / USerPage
Profile Picture Avatars
Gadets
Widgetbar
Search Preferences

"Security"[edit]

Confluence BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Confluence Groups Groupmanager
Restricted Pages PageAccess
Unlimited Anonymous Users Unlimited Anonymous Users
Public Signup Register
Captcha Captcha
Centralized User Management LDAPAuthentication
Failed Login Captcha Captcha
WikiBouncer
LDAP & AD LDAP & AD
SSO SSO
Space Permissions PermissionManager
Secure Sign-up -
Space Permissions PermissionManager
Invite Users -

Extensions and features of (BlueSpice) MediaWiki[edit]

Topic BlueSpice pro MediaWiki SMW
Templating and Semantic Semantic MediaWiki
SemanticForms
Semantic Result Formats
ExternalData
??ProjectCalender
QA ArticleInfo
Maintenance Reports
div. SpecialPages
Reminder
Expiry
Review
Flagged Revs
ReadingConfirmation
Book ChapterHierarchy
Book collection and export
Editorial Tools WikiExplorer
Authors
Readers (German description)
Administration Nuke
Statistics
RenameUser
ExtensionInfo
Groupmanager
Preferences
UserManager
Shoutbox
DynamicPageList
ContextMenu